By Edward E. Baptist
Published by Basic Books
A Member if the Perseus Books Group
A review
The
educational system in the United States exposes students to a history that has
little resemblance to the actual events that transpired in our past. The history taught in the schools of this
country gives a picture of a nation that has had its troubles, but has triumphed
in spite of those obstacles.
Gordon
S. Wood a Brown University professor gave this basic view in his Pulitzer Prize
winning book Radicalism of the American
Revolution. “But there is no denying
the wonder of it (the American Revolution) and the real earthly benefits it
brought to the hitherto neglected and despised masses of common laboring
people.”
There
are other authors who have given us a different view of the past. Some of these include James Loewen’s book, Lies My Teacher Told Me, Howard Zinn’s book,
A People’s History of the United States, and
my favorite is a book edited by George Novack, America’s Revolutionary Heritage.
Edward
Baptist gives us a new and fresh view of the roots of how the economy of the
United States transformed the world in his book, Half Has Never Been Told – Slavery and the Making of American
Capitalism. In his book, Baptist
looked at the theories of Thomas Malthus who argued that with the growth of the
population, humanity would eventually run out of food.
Clearly
Malthus wasn’t concerned with the gross inequality of his day. However, Malthus felt that based on the
productive forces of that time, humanity wouldn’t have enough food to feed
everyone.
Baptist
gives the evidence of how all this changed with the industrial revolution. The beginnings of this industrialization took
place with the transformation of cotton fiber into cloth. All of this depended on the slave labor of
the United States.
In
order to fully appreciate Baptist’s argument we need to look at the terminology
he used to support the theme of his book.
The following are some of the words and phrases Baptist used:
Coffle – a line of slaves who were
chained together at the neck with the arms chained behind their backs. These salves, chained together in coffles,
sometimes walked for hundreds of miles so slave owners might turn a profit.
Enslaved migrants - Slaves who might have been separated from their families to travel
via ship or coffle to work in the areas of Mississippi and Louisiana primarily
for the cultivation and picking of cotton.
Torture – The routine method used to
coerce slaves to become more productive.
Calibrated torture – The amount of pain
or torture inflicted on slaves by slave owners and their hirelings to coerce
slaves to increase their productivity.
Slave labor camps - Historians have called these plantations. These were the places where slaves toiled and
were tortured when they failed to meet the expectations of slave owners.
Hardware Store – The place where slave
owners purchased instruments of torture.
Whipping machine – This is Baptist’s
term to identify the routine torture slaves endured to meet the expectations of
slave owners.
Baptist
included several tables and drawings to illustrate various points he attempted
to make. In one of these tables he
showed how the amount of cotton slaves produced increased dramatically until
the Civil War. Most of this cotton was
shipped to the British port of Liverpool and then transported to
Manchester. This table showed how the
amount of cotton that was spun and then woven also increased dramatically during
those years.
However,
while the supply of cotton and cloth increased, the price of raw cotton
decreased. While cotton prices
decreased, there was a sharp increase in the price of the finished cloth. This trend is typical to the capitalist
system. As technology makes it easier to
produce commodities, the prices of finished commodities continue to
increase.
This
reality put a tremendous amount of pressure on slave owners to increase the
productivity of slaves. All slaves were
routinely tortured in various ways. In
order to adapt to this system, slaves needed to continuously work from sun up
to sun down at a seemingly inhuman pace.
Baptist
wrote about how slaves needed to use both hands simultaneously in order to meet
these increasing quotas. He argued that
this is not natural, and the slave needed to loose him or herself in this work
to be effective. To even stand erect
while toiling under the hot sun might provoke a beating.
Coercion of labor today
While
I was reading this passage in Baptist’s book, I thought about my own experience
of working in an auto-parts manufacturing facility during the 1990’s. I remember attending a meeting where a
corporate officer demanded that we increase production or the company would
close the plant down.
I
remember working faster than I thought possible in order to meet these new
requirements. At times I worked
alongside robots where I worked so fast that I had the feeling of flying. While we met the company demands of
increasing productivity and improving quality, the corporation closed the plant
anyway. About 2,500 workers who produced
an enormous amount of wealth for various corporations were thrown out into the
street like used garbage.
I
raise this experience to demonstrate that there is a certain similarity of
thinking by the owners of wealth towards the chattel slaves of the past and
workers today.
The economics of slavery
Like
any commodity, cotton produced under slave labor conditions, had its periods of
boom and bust. Initially slave owners
transported their human property to the Mississippi Delta, where the climate
was ideal for cotton cultivation. As
cotton production increased, prices declined and slave owners weren’t able to
meet their expenses.
Initially
bankers sold bonds to rescue the slave owners.
This meant that slaves would be confiscated and sold in the event of
bankruptcy. Breaking up slave families
was never a concern of those who viewed them as property.
Slave
owners got around their financial problems with the GTT. This meant “Go To
Texas.” After Texas became independent
of Mexico, slave owners transported slaves to Texas in order to avoid
confiscation.
After
Texas became a state, slave owners attempted other measures to avoid
bankruptcy. They pressured the government
to open up more lands for slavery.
As
early as 1830 the United States government passed the Indian Removal Act. This
act, in effect, stole millions of acres of land from its original
inhabitants. In the trail of tears the Cherokee (Tsalagi) nation was forced to
march about 1,200 miles to their new homes in an alien land known as
Oklahoma. About 5,000 Cherokee died in
this forced relocation. The motivation
behind the Indian Removal Act was to open up a vast area for slave labor.
Slave
owners also made a habit of defaulting on their loans. This might be of interest to university
students who have been saddled with astronomical loans to pay for their
education. While the United States
government allowed slave owners to default on their loans, this same government
will not allow college graduates to default on their loans by declaring
bankruptcy.
Slave labor and the world
We
might also think about how the production of cotton by slave labor influenced
the world. On the one hand, this labor was
the very foundation of the industrialization of the world. This was the beginning of the revolutions in
communication, transportation, housing, food production, education, and medical
care.
On
the other hand, this labor gave an immense amount of power to the British
ruling powers. At this time Britain was
the world’s super-power.
Friedrich
Engels lived in Manchester at the time when workers spun and wove cotton fiber
produced by slaves in the factories of that city. He wrote about what he saw in his book The Condition of the Working Class in
England. While workers in Britain
were technically free at that time, they needed to spend every waking hour
toiling for their employers. Engels
documented the miserable conditions British workers faced in order to produce
obscene profits for their employers.
The
British ruling powers also forced the Chinese to import opium during the Opium
Wars. Because opium purchases and this
war bankrupted the Chinese, millions starved to death while the British profited. The people of Ireland, India, and Brazil had
similar experiences where millions starved to death while the British profited
from investments in those countries.
Conflicting ideas about what it meant to be a human being
Under
these conditions the rape of slave women was routine. Rape is not an attempt at sexual
gratification, but an expression of power by a demented man. However, Baptist argues that during the era
of slavery slave owners felt that raping slaves was an expression of manhood.
Rape
wasn’t just an expression of power by a slave owner over a slave. It was an expression of power over citizens
who did not own slaves. Rape was also an
expression of power over the slave owner’s wife who clearly did not want her
husband to be raping women.
We
can also say that inflicting torture on slaves was also seen as an expression
of manhood. As Baptist has shown, this
was a routine part of what it meant to produce cotton for the market.
On
the other hand, the slave had a different idea of what it meant to be a human
being. Today, many people might think
that slaves should have been more determined in their efforts to free
themselves from this bondage.
Baptist
gives the evidence showing how it was nearly impossible to launch a slave rebellion. Baptist showed how the Haitian slave
revolution did succeed. However,
hundreds of thousands of Haitian slaves lost their lives in their attempt to be
free. The slave owners of this country
took steps to make sure that a Haitian style revolution would never happen.
Only
a tiny percentage of slaves managed to escape these conditions. Understanding this reality, slave owners
would not tolerate even a slight expression of defiance. One challenge to their authority would only
lead to many, many others.
Today,
there is a common conception that to be a righteous human being entails a
struggle against oppression. This idea
is contained in the Declaration of
Independence. This document is a
list of grievances the colonists of the thirteen colonies had against the
British royalty. It argued that people
not only have a right but “a duty” to fight against tyranny. While these are nice words, Baptist shows us
that a successful fight against the clear tyranny of slavery in this country
was nearly impossible until the Civil War.
So,
understanding that revolt and escape were not real possibilities, slaves needed
to find ways of enduring the seemingly unendurable. They
did this with thousands of acts of solidarity.
They understood that the only way for people to endure these conditions
was to watch out for one another.
Clearly this didn’t always happen, but these acts of solidarity made it
possible to endure.
Baptist
pointed to a slave who lost his family when they were sold at auction. This slave took care of a child who lost his
parents at this same auction. Another
slave lost her family in an auction and had understandable feelings of
despair. With the supportive acts of
other slaves and her belief in religion, she was able to overcome her despair
and found the strength to survive.
We
can also look at escaped slaves like Frederick Douglass and Harriet Tubman who
energized the abolitionist movement.
Baptist argues that all progressive social movements have their roots
with those slaves who waged an uncompromising struggle to end the system of
chattel slavery in this country.
Even
the music we listen to today has its roots in the system of slavery. Before reading this book, I was of the
opinion that much of the music we hear had its roots in European and African
musical styles. Baptist argues that this
is an inadequate explanation. We also
need to look at the fact that the experience of slavery also influenced the
music slaves performed. This experience
gave us the foundation for the musical styles of the Blues, Jazz, Rhythm and
Blues, Rock and Roll, as well as Rap.
So,
here Baptist shows us two views of what it means to be a human being. One view is a criminal attitude advocating
for the worst kind of anti-social behavior, all for the sake of money. The other view is about seeing one’s self as
a part of a community and understanding that an injury to one is an injury to
all.
We
might also consider that ex-slaves finally were allowed to become soldiers in
the Union Army. This took place when
many union soldiers were demoralized due to the immense damage caused by the
war. The 250,000 African American
soldiers were necessary to the union effort to win the war. This was one of the main reasons why President
Lincoln signed his Emancipation
Proclamation.
Slave labor and capitalist productivity
One
of the ideas that I learned from Baptist’s book was that slave labor in the
cultivation of cotton was actually more productive than the productivity of
freed slaves. Baptist argues that the
main reason for this difference was the fact that slave owners were able to
coerce slaves with torture.
In
Frederick Douglass’ autobiography he gave a different view with respect to
labor productivity in the ship building industry at that time. Douglass reported that three workers in a
northern ship building port could do the work of about twelve slaves in
Baltimore performing the same job.
I
think we can recognize the reality of both these arguments. When machinery is introduced to the
workplace, skilled workers are a necessity.
While workers have an incentive to develop skills, the main priority of
slaves is to be free. This, I believe,
explains why there were very few scientific advancements during the 600 years
of the Roman Empire that also relied on slave labor.
Reparations for slavery
Reading
Baptist’s book, I thought about the question: When will Black people be
compensated for the immense price their ancestors paid? As Baptist has shown, the labor of slaves was
an essential ingredient to transform the world.
Yet the government in this country has never seriously considered this
issue. I believe we also need to ask the
question: Why?
While
the institution of chattel slavery has been, for the most part eliminated in
this country, the primary goal of the government continues to be support for
those who control the flow of money.
While one out of every six people in this country doesn’t have enough
food to eat, the government has dumped literally trillions of dollars on some of the most affluent people in the
world. They have called this scheme quantitative easing.
My
opinion is that Black people want what we all want. We want to be free. This means free from hunger, as well as free
from poverty. As Aretha Franklyn and
Otis Redding said in their song, they want respect. As Etta James said in one of her songs,
people also want security. I don’t believe these are unreasonable
requests. Reading Edward Baptist’s book
we can understand that Black people have clearly earned these things a long
time ago.
Until
we have a government that recognizes this basic reality, my opinion is that
none of us has any right to say that we are free.